salomons.coachsalomons.coach
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Services
  • Testimonials
  • Session Scheduler
  • Contact
  • Change language to Nederlands
Back
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Services
  • Testimonials
  • Session Scheduler
  • Contact
  • Change language to Nederlands
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Blog
  • “Not Strategic Enough”: The Label That Hides the Real Problem

Blog

15 Mar 2026

“Not Strategic Enough”: The Label That Hides the Real Problem

  • By salomons.coach
  • In Blog, Improving personal leadership effectiveness
Executive summary

The assessment ‘not strategic enough’ can sound precise while concealing a poorly defined expectation. A leader may be criticised for insufficient strategic contribution when decision rights, access to information or the executive team’s behaviour make that contribution difficult.

Before prescribing development, organisations should examine what strategic thinking actually requires in the role and whether the surrounding system enables it. Leaders need explicit standards, useful feedback and access to the conversations that shape direction. The article challenges the assumption that every perceived capability gap belongs to the individual. Sometimes the label reveals more about the organisation’s operating model than about the person receiving it.

Executive Team Coaching

I read an article of someone who overheard it in a café recently. Two people over open laptops and half-eaten lunch. One leaning in, lowering their voice slightly: “She just needs to be more strategic.”

It resonanted directly as I have heard these type of qualifications before. So, I felt for the woman they were talking about. Not because the observation was necessarily wrong, but because it almost certainly wasn’t the real diagnosis.

“Not strategic enough” is one of the most common things said about people who are otherwise highly regarded but seem to have hit an invisible career ceiling. And it is almost never the full story.

What the Label Actually Means

Before we can address a development need, we need to understand what we’re actually observing. In my experience coaching executive teams, “not strategic enough” is a phrase that carries a surprisingly wide range of meanings:

  • She challenges decisions in ways that make the leadership team uncomfortable, and they’ve decided that’s a “her” problem.
  • She doesn’t socialise her thinking upwards before meetings, so her ideas land without context and feel less considered than they are.
  • She was promoted into a role with no clarity about what “strategic” actually means here, given no support, and the organisation is now surprised she’s struggling.
  • She is the one who says what others think but don’t say — which makes her uncomfortable for the system, not strategically weak.

Each of these situations calls for a completely different response. And yet they all receive the same label.

The Team Coach’s First Move: Treat the Label as Data

When a leadership team brings this kind of feedback about one of their members, the team coach’s first move is not to work on the individual. It is to get curious about the label itself.

Questions worth asking the team:

  • Who decided this, and on what basis?
  • What specific behaviours are you observing — and in which contexts?
  • What does “strategic” actually mean here, in this organisation, at this level?
  • Has she ever been told directly, clearly, and with concrete examples?

Often the team cannot answer these questions cleanly. That itself is information — and it shifts the focus where it usually belongs: onto the system, not just the individual.

The Systemic Function of the Label

In team dynamics, labels like “not strategic enough” frequently serve a function that has little to do with the person being labelled. They can:

  • Deflect discomfort — she challenges the status quo, and this is the socially acceptable way to sideline that.
  • Maintain hierarchy — her thinking threatens someone’s position or authority.
  • Avoid accountability — the team promoted her, shaped her context, and now externalises the problem onto her.
  • Signal group norms — “strategic” often means “plays the game the way we play it.”

A skilled team coach names these possibilities — carefully, but directly. Leaving them unnamed is itself a form of collusion.

“Before calling someone insufficiently strategic, check whether you ever gave them room to decide strategically.”

Jan Salomons

Three Situations That Look the Same — But Aren’t

Before any intervention makes sense, the team coach needs to diagnose which of these three situations they are actually in:

What it looks likeWhat is actually happening
She needs developmentGenuine skill gap — coachable with proper support and honest feedback
She needs translationHer thinking is sound but does not land well in this culture or with this audience
The team needs confrontingThe label is a power move, a deflection, or a symptom of low psychological safety

Moving too quickly to individual coaching — without this diagnosis — risks colluding with the very dynamic that’s getting in the way.

The Psychological Safety Angle

If she genuinely challenges decisions and that makes the leadership team uncomfortable, that is a psychological safety issue in the team — not a strategic thinking issue in her.

Amy Edmondson’s research is instructive here: in teams with low psychological safety, dissenting voices tend to be managed out, relabelled, or marginalised over time. The team coach’s job is to make this dynamic visible — and to help the team see what they are losing by doing so.

The sharpest question for the leadership team: What does it cost you when the person who sees things differently gets labelled rather than heard?

When Individual Coaching Is Warranted: Do It Honestly

If, after proper diagnosis, there genuinely is a development need — then the coaching conversation needs to be honest about what is actually happening.

Not: “you need to be more strategic.” But: here is how your thinking is landing with this specific audience, here is what is getting in the way, and here is what you can do differently.

Not sanitised performance review language — “can sometimes come across as” and “might consider” — conversations that reach the point and then pull back at the last moment. That kind of feedback softens the edges but doesn’t help anyone.

The goal is not to fix her to fit the system. It is to help her navigate it with full awareness of what that system is. That is a crucial distinction.

The Harder Conversation: With the Team

The most important work in these situations often happens not with the individual, but with the leadership team itself. The questions that matter most:

  • Are you modelling the strategic thinking you are asking of her?
  • Are you giving her the room, the information, and the sponsorship she needs to operate at that level?
  • Did you define what “strategic” actually looks like in this role, in this organisation, before you promoted her?
  • Is this label protecting someone — or something — in this team from being examined?

That last question is the one most leadership teams resist. And it is usually the most important one.

A Final Thought

The leaders I have worked with who carried the “not strategic enough” label for years often turn out to be among the sharpest thinkers in their organisation. They did not need a new set of skills. They needed someone to help them see how they were landing their thinking — and an organisation willing to look honestly at the context it had created.

Strategic thinking can absolutely be developed. But you cannot develop it in someone if you have not first understood what is actually getting in their way.

Before we write someone off as not strategic enough, it is worth asking whether we are truly modelling strategic thinking ourselves.

Tags:Executive judgmentfeedbackleadership development
  • Share:
salomons.coach
Jan Salomons is a seasoned leader/executive who shares his knowledge and experience as an executive mentor/coach/trainer as well as a transformation and operations excellence expert. He has over 35 years of experience working with senior leaders across more than 55 countries, and is an elected member of the Harvard Business Review Advisory Council.

You may also like

How to uncover hidden struggles behind green dashboards

  • 15 November 2026
  • by salomons.coach
  • in Blog
Green dashboards can hide rework, recovery costs and unfinished work. Learn what operational leaders need to see behind the...
The Ultimate Guide to the Impossible Operating Plan
9 November 2026
Businesswoman standing and presenting to colleagues around a glass-walled conference room table.
New Leader, Existing Team, Team Reset
16 October 2026
Infographic titled 'What gets seen, gets repeated' showing two columns: left red section 'Visible. Immediate. Reactive.' with a red alert siren, a worker on the phone, factory silhouettes, and a '22:00' breakdown; caption 'IS A HERO.' Right green section 'Invisible. Deliberate. Proactive.' with a worker at a laptop displaying a rising graph and icons labeled 'Identify risk', 'Address causes', 'Prevent failure'; caption 'WEEKS EARLIER – PREVENTION' and 'IS ALMOST INVISIBLE.' Bottom banner reads 'Shift recognition. Reward prevention. Build resilient operations.' and shows salomons.coach.
What Gets Seen, Gets Repeated – Firefighters vs Preventers
26 September 2026

Leave A Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Categories

  • Blog (176)
  • Building high-performing leadership teams (25)
  • Closing leadership capability gaps (24)
  • Improving personal leadership effectiveness (46)
  • Leading across cultures and boundaries (15)
  • Leading through uncertainty and crisis (11)
  • Making better leadership decisions (4)
  • Making change stick (12)
  • Navigating leadership and career transitions (13)
  • Sustaining performance under pressure (15)
  • Turning strategy into operational results (11)
  • Video (16)

Recent Posts

How to uncover hidden struggles behind green dashboards
15Nov,2026
The Ultimate Guide to the Impossible Operating Plan
09Nov,2026
Businesswoman standing and presenting to colleagues around a glass-walled conference room table.
New Leader, Existing Team, Team Reset
16Oct,2026

Tags

accountability (10) adaptability (5) AI & leadership (5) authenticity (10) Career transitions (11) Change execution (13) Coaching effectiveness (9) Coaching tools (18) communication (17) cross-cultural leadership (15) Cultural frameworks (12) decision making (6) Dialogue & conflict (7) emotional-intelligence (8) executive-coaching (15) Executive judgment (5) Executive presence (7) feedback (6) Focus & priorities (11) Global teams (5) Leadership behaviour (22) leadership development (16) Leadership transitions (5) learning culture (9) Neuroscience & learning (7) Operational excellence (8) Operational governance (6) Organisational culture (15) Organisational transformation (7) Ownership & delegation (6) Performance measurement (8) Personal resilience (10) psychological safety (14) Purpose & values (8) Recovery & wellbeing (7) Redundancy & outplacement (6) Research & evidence (8) self-awareness (43) Stress & coping (10) systems thinking (8) team alignment (6) Team effectiveness (15) trust (7) VUCA & uncertainty (9) Work-life boundaries (4)
All posts - searchable table
Recent videos
the-adhd-watch-list-hero

The Best ADHD Videos for Leaders: Science, Stories, Strategy

In 14 July 2026
No Comment
Female speaker on stage delivering a TEDx talk, with a headset mic and gesturing, while a lower-third bio identifies her as a professor of organizational behaviour.

The Authenticity Paradox | Professor Herminia Ibarra 

Brooks – Harvard – on Happiness

Happiness as a Leadership Strategy

L360 youyrownjourney landing page L360

Find your true purpose

Leadership thinking you can use

The Leadership Compass

For the decisions, conversations and changes you need to lead.

Receive articles grounded in executive experience, coaching and the realities of running an operation.

Read an example article ↗

Newsletter Form

Two short welcome emails in the first week, then articles about every two weeks. Unsubscribe at any time.

Privacy policy

GET IN TOUCH

Salomons.Coach
KvK: 72129131
+31 6 53 89 75 67

jan@salomons.coach

The Netherlands

USEFUL LINKS

  • About
  • Privacy policy
  • Term & Conditions
  • Refund & Returns
  • Payment policy
  • Digital Policy
  • Methodology & Sources

LinkedIn

  • Linkedin

salomons.coach by J.K. Salomons Holding B.V., 2018-2027

Change language to Nederlands